I second dom - Goodyear Gatorback is touted to be one of the best ones you can get for a 9th gen Corolla. On my old Matrix - I was going through the OEM Bando belts every 10K-15K miles. Switched to Gatorback at 60K miles, was perfect all the way to the point that the car got totaled in an accident at 120K. Switched over my Corolla belt at ~160K miles, now with 255K miles - that belt still looks good!
Of the ones you listed, I would go with a Dayco belt (assuming this is the Poly-Rib one - 3yr warranty, special compound rubber). Duralast is a like a mid-priced version, conventional construction, Valuecraft is a price point belt, ie. - this the one to put on if you want to dump your car.
Gates and Masterpro are actually the same belt - two different names. Gates is a well known brand name, but quality hasn't been as good as it used to be. I've actually had pretty terrible luck with Gates hoses and belts, been lucky, they gave out close to home - though could have been a bad batch, but I stopped using them several years ago - don't want to risk being stranded because of a failure.