I used to work at a shop that did a lot of custom exhaust work. Did a few nice bolt-ons (SS, all the bolts lined up, sounded sweet!), did a few crappy bolt-ons (nothing lined up, exhaust tips were crooked, etc), but mainly one-offs.
OE exhaust is designed with best performance/economy in mind. If you are going to replace the exhaust for performance reasons, best thing is to get something aftermarket. If you really want performance, get a full bolt on system designed for your car. You will get a gain.
However, can you really feel the difference? Prob not.
I have driven a lot of different vehicles. a 1-2hp gain is not something you will notice. on a car, even a 10hp gain is not something you really "feel" (on a bike, you notice smaller increases much easier).
With that said, if you have a shop build you one, dep on the person working on it, you may get an awsome sounding system with good performance, or you may get a different sounding system (vs. oe) with no performance gains.
All depends on whether the person knows what he is doing.
Although I did a lot of custom work, and it looked awsome, I doublt the work I did gave any real performance gain. might have freed up as much as 20hp (dep on the vehicle and system), but I am sure i also killed the torque.
Most of the customers I had felt that their car had become faster. However, I think it was mostly psychological. Its louder, therefore, it must be faster.
The very few that did dyno before and after did not show overall better performance (ie lower torque).
Biggest thing I noticed was how HEAVY the OE exhaust is. The can alone weighed as much as the entire replacement system.
Part of the increased peppiness may have just been a weight issue? (naw... prob not enough to feel...)
hmmm... turning into a long rant... (sorry).
My first piece of advise would be not to mess with the exhaust yet. Its only a year old. I assume you still have the factory warranty.
Dep on what kind of work you do on the vehicle, it may void the warranty. You have a nice car. Wait until its no longer under warrantly before putting it under the knife.
If you absolutely feel that you need to change it, make sure you get one that gurantees you that it will not effect warranty. This should limit your choices.
btw robbie,
it is spelled SOME.
good luck
tdk.