I know that it's human nature to want to put the "best" oil in your car, and I've been guilty of doing this on other cars as well. Mobil 1 is an excellent synthetic motor oil. The benefits of all of the other synthetics are pretty close to Mobil 1, so you can't go wrong with any of them.
But conventional oils have improved dramatically over the last few years. They're far better than the oil your parents used in their 2-ton rust buckets. I've been using cheap conventional oil in my '95 Corolla (primarily Super Tech - the cheap stuff) and I now have 211,000 miles on my car.
So you have to ask yourself how long you plan on keeping your car, and whether the added cost of synthetic is worth it. If you had a high performance car that saw some track time or if your engine was going to see sub-zero temps before the next oil change, then that's a different story. In my opinion, it's better for the engine to have frequent oil changes (3-4000 miles) and keep the oil level topped off than spending the extra on synthetic oil.