Some good tire choices - based on what you had before (the ones I listed below are ones that I've run personally or have colleagues that gave good reviews on):
NOTE: I listed the UTQG ratings as well - but you should always treat them as only usuable in comparing tires from the same manufacturer - as different manufacturers use different methods to determine these "universal" ratings.
BFGoodrich g-Force T/A KDW 300 AA A
- massive amounts of dry grip
- very good wet performance
- lasts surprising long for a performance oriented tire
BFGoodrich g-ForceTM Sport 300 AA A
- massive amounts of dry grip
- very good wet performance
- lasts surprising long for a performance oriented tire
Dunlop SP Sport 9000 280 AA A
- massive amounts of dry grip
- very good wet performance
- pretty good lifespan, probably similar to what you had before
Dunlop SP Sport MAXX 240 AA A
- massive amounts of dry grip
- very good wet performance
- pretty good lifespan, probably similar to what you had before
Falken FK-452 300 AA A
- massive amounts of dry grip
- very good wet performance
- lasts surprising long for a performance oriented tire
- probably one of the best bang for the buck tires
Goodyear Eagle F1 GS-D3 280 AA A
- massive amounts of dry grip
- very good wet performance
- pretty good lifespan, probably similar to what you had before- probably one of the more expensive ones in the bunch (Michelins equivalents are more expensive)
- love/hate kind of tire depending on conditions
Hankook Ventus R-S2 200 A A
- massive amounts of dry grip
- decent wet performance
- lasts surprising short (most of the Scooby guys have them wear out in less than 10K - but the tire is like a rubber gumball, great for dry)
Kumho Ecsta MX 220 AA A
- massive amounts of dry grip
- decent wet performance
- lasts about average a performance oriented tire
- probably one of the best bang for the buck tires
Kumho Ecsta SPT 320 AA A
- massive amounts of dry grip
- decent wet performance
- lasts surprising long for a performance oriented tire
- probably one of the best bang for the buck tires
- some love them , some hate them - similar to the 712s
Toyo Proxes T1R 280 AA A
- massive amounts of dry grip
- very good wet performance
- pretty good lifespan, probably similar to what you had before- probably one of the best bang for the buck tires
Yokohama AVS ES100 280 AA A
- massive amounts of dry grip
- very good wet performance
- lasts surprising long for a performance oriented tire (I've gotten about 20K with HARD driving on these - very progressive tire, can recover well from a break away)
- probably one of the best bang for the buck tires
AVON tech and Michelins have some really nice ones too - but I haven't played with them myself or have people close that have them to test.