A possible ouchie here. Havoline Long Life coolant - does it say Dex-Cool anywhere on the bottle? I'm hoping no, if it does say Dex-Cool - might be in for some trouble.
True, most coolants on the market are EG based and have some sort of additive package. The problems comes in with the makeup of that additive package. Both Toyota Red (premixed one is Pink) and the Havoline Long Life coolant - uses OAT package to help ensure long life and are silicate free. Here's the difference, Toyota coolants have a heavy dose of phosphate to work as a "buffering" agent in the coolant (not sure if this applies to Red coolant). Havoline/Dex-Cool is phosphate free. What the phosphate does is keep the coolant from eating the aluminum in the radiator. The part is the OAT packages. OAT are supposed to take care of that (they are aluminum safe) - but even with the OAT package, it is different between the two. Toyota uses a Hybrid OAT package - sebacate base, Havoline Long Life Coolant/Dex-Cool/Texaco/etc. use a conventional OAT - 2-ethylhexanoic acid base.
Dex-Cool is OEM on most GM vehicles build after 1996 - most have had some "weird" issues pop up if the coolant wasn't introduced the correct way. Most shops say that before switching to Dex-Cool or similar coolants (assuming Dex-Cool is not the OEM mix for the target car) - you have to flush atleast 90% of the old coolant out of the system and distilled water is highly recommended for use. There are some horror stories of people mixing green with Dex-Cool - the take home message is not to mix them. Introducing tap water can also cause some headaches. The additive package can cause the minerals to precipitate out of solution - this means crystal clear coolant, but heavy deposits all over the cooling system.
I'd pop the radiator cap off and take a look at the fins inside the radiator. There should be no film or deposits anywhere in there. Flush the system with distilled water until the drain water runs clear. Probably a good idea to pop the thermostat off and take a peek in there as well - helps with the flushing process.
Doesn't mean you cannot run Havoline in a Toyota - just have to make sure that all the preparations were followed out carefully - to avoid any compatibility issues.