Here in Ontario, Canada, car insurance is outrageously expensive. I pay $150 per month in Canadian funds which is about $115 US. My rate would be considered reasonable compared to others. Some people (young people) are charged $500 per month or more. I have heard stories of new immigrants to Canada actually not being able to get insurance at all.
I am 41, single, no accidents, but no real driving history as I have only owned a car since last May.
Having an accident is devastating in terms of one's premium. Your premium will probably go up by hundreds of dollars per month. The result? Many people are not reporting accidents and are paying cash. I personally take the view that insurance should be "saved" for a major accident. If you put in a claim for a small fender bender, yes they will pay the claim, but they will brutally extract the monies from you over the next few years with horrendous premiums.
It is not uncommon for insurance premiums to be higher than the lease payments on a vehicle.